As a three-year starting lineman on the Middletown football team, Evan was selected to All-Area and All-League teams and was first team All-State and All-Big School in his senior year. He was a team captain and lettered in basketball and track and field for the Knights. As a University of Virginia signee, Evan became the first MHS football player to ever receive a full Division I scholarship. He started 39 games over four seasons for the Cavaliers, including three bowl games, was a team captain at UVA, and was twice named ALL-Academic ACC. He was selected in his senior year to play in both the Blue-Gray Senior Bowl Game and the East-West Shrine Game. He returned to Frederick County and has devoted time as an advocate for individuals with Downs Syndrome. All-Star High School and College Football Player